A critical appraisal of Marshal Hodgson’s view of Islam vis-à-vis cumulative and discursive traditions

Basit Öğe Kaydı
dc.contributor.authorShafi, Mukerem Mifta
dc.contributor.otherMedeniyetler İttifakı Enstitüsü, Medeniyet Araştırmaları Ana Bilim Dalı
dc.date.accessioned2019-03-14T13:50:23Z
dc.date.available2019-03-14T13:50:23Z
dc.date.issued2018
dc.departmentİHÜ, Medeniyetler İttifakı Enstitüsü, Medeniyet Araştırmaları Ana Bilim Dalı
dc.description.abstractThe article engages closely with Marshall C. Hodgson's view of Islam in his theory of Islamicate civilization. Despite his methodological consciousness and various revisions he introduced in the study of Islamic civilization, he failed to do the same in his conception of Islam. This contribution looks at three relevant aspects of Hodgson's take on Islam. Apart from explaining problems inherent in his conception of Islam, I examine the relative efficacy of the view shared in some important ways between Hodgson and Smith. To this end, first, I argue that Hodgson's every allusion of Islam breathes dualism. Even though he was indeed well aware of this dualism, he barely succeeded in accounting for it, either historically or in Islamic tradition. Second, I try to make a theoretical link between this view of Hodgson and Wilfred C. Smith. I also compliment this with a review of some of the key counter arguments posited. Third, the article ends with a brief comparative assessment of W. C. Smith's cumulative tradition, Talal Asad's discursive tradition, and Shahab Ahmed's "coherence" in the face of "outright contradictions" thesis.
dc.identifier.citationShafi, M. M. (2018). A critical appraisal of Marshal Hodgson’s view of Islam vis-à-vis cumulative and discursive traditions. İnsan & Toplum, 8(2), pp. 33-50.
dc.identifier.doi10.12658/M0234
dc.identifier.endpage50
dc.identifier.issn2146-7099
dc.identifier.issn2602-2745
dc.identifier.issue2
dc.identifier.startpage33
dc.identifier.urihttps://doi.org/10.12658/M0234
dc.identifier.urihttps://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12154/639
dc.identifier.volume8
dc.identifier.wosWOS:000455201700003
dc.identifier.wosqualityQ4
dc.indekslendigikaynakWeb of Science
dc.institutionauthorShafi, Mukerem Mifta
dc.language.isoen
dc.publisherİlmi Etüdler Derneği
dc.relation.ihupublicationcategory117
dc.relation.ispartofİnsan & Toplum
dc.relation.publicationcategoryMakale - Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi - Kurum Öğretim Elemanı
dc.relation.publicationcategoryÖğrenci
dc.rightsinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
dc.subjectIslam
dc.subjectIslamic
dc.subjectCumulative Tradition
dc.subjectDiscursive Tradition
dc.titleA critical appraisal of Marshal Hodgson’s view of Islam vis-à-vis cumulative and discursive traditions
dc.typeArticle
dspace.entity.typePublication
relation.isOrgUnitOfPublication65117131-5bf1-442c-8ca2-8f4d8edc1edf
relation.isOrgUnitOfPublication.latestForDiscovery65117131-5bf1-442c-8ca2-8f4d8edc1edf

Dosyalar

Orijinal paket
Listeleniyor 1 - 1 / 1
Küçük Resim
İsim:
Shafi-Mukerrem Miftah.pdf
Boyut:
284.2 KB
Biçim:
Adobe Portable Document Format
Açıklama:
Tam Metin / Full Text
İndir
Lisans paketi
Listeleniyor 1 - 1 / 1
[ N/A ]
İsim:
license.txt
Boyut:
1.52 KB
Biçim:
Item-specific license agreed upon to submission
Açıklama:
İndir

Koleksiyon

Medeniyetler İttifakı Enstitüsü Diğer Yayınlar Koleksiyonu
WoS İndeksli Yayınlar Koleksiyonu